Friday, May 05, 2006
More results
Brent - No Overall Controll gain from Labour
Barnet - Conservative hold
Barking & Dagenham - Labour hold
Havering - Conservative gain from No Overall Control
Hounslow - No Overall Controll gain from Labour
Southwark - No Overall Control (with Labour equalling the Lib Dem total)
Greenwich - Labour hold
That leaves Hackney, Tower Hamlets and Newham. According to the RESPECT website Tower Hamlets has recounts in some wards this afternoon with Labour possibly hanging on, but RESPECT are determined to force a rerun in another ward. The Lib Dems have collapsed and the Conservatives have made a long await breakthrough, building on the by-election when they won their first seat here since the 1930s and now winning seven councillors.
Deckchairs on the Titanic reshuffled
In a bold and imaginitive move John Reid moves to fill a major vacancy. Meanwhile John Prescott loses his departmental responsibilities.
Does Blair really believe these are the sort of changes the public want?
Thoughts from the local elections
00:23 - Tony King has reminded us that on the low turnouts in local elections the level of informedness about local issues amongst those voting is quite high. Would it really be such a good thing to bring the remaining 60%+ of voters who have decided they aren't inspired to have a say and force them to cast votes?
00:27 - Geoff Hoon and John Reid have just demonstrated that at least one is off message about whether or not the Cabinet reshuffle in the morning is official. Hoon is going to Downing Street so probably won't be sacked (he's been so invisible lately that Blair must value highly any Cabinet Minister not generating bad headlines). John Reid has in the past got a new job in almost every successive reshuffle so may actually be trying to deflect speculation. Who honestly wants to be Home Secretary at a time like this?
(My own suggestion is a bit radical. Since a minister who can get a firm hold on a department is needed at the Home Office, and since Blair is always publicly praising Gordon Brown, why not give Brown some all rounded experience in non economic policy by sending him to get the Home Office in order?)
00:35 - On the local news round up for London it's reported that Barking & Dagenham has seen a massive surge in turnout up to about 38%. This could mean a surge in votes for the BNP. Also there were earlier reports that a lot of votes in wards without BNP candidates were spoilt with people writing "BNP" on the ballot paper and there have even been voters complaining about not being able to vote for the BNP.
00:37 - Labour is worried in Tower Hamlets, the home borough of my university. Today I was standing outside a council owned door while a lot of people went in to make marks on provided paper - only this was for exams! The exam hall is just round the corner from the Bethnal Green & Bow Labour Party office and "RESPECT" sent their megaphone car around the streets to broadcast an upbeat message. (I was on the verge of charging out to the queue at the traffic lights to demand that party showed some respect to the students trying to concentrate inside!) We'll see if George Galloway's Big Brother antics have left much impression there.
00:45 - David Dimbleby to Sarah Teather: "At the moment the Conservatives are up fifty [councillors]. You're up three." Teather has declared that she'd be satisfied with "net gains". Is this a reflection of the Lib Dems admitting they're basically just standing still? Do they need to "raise their game"?00:49 - BBC1 has a box at the bottom of the screen listing results so far - but on my small television screen some results are getting cropped, especially the BNP results.
00:53 - BBC News' results so far has it even worse for Sarah Teather. Currently it shows the Conservatives up fifty-four councillors and the Lib Dems down two. That's with seven hundred and thirty-eight seats declared so far.
00:58 - A report from Tower Hamlet shows the star of Celebrity Big Brother arriving and his party feeling confident of making gains, as are the Conservatives and Lib Dems. It seems the Labour leader may lose his seat.(By the way if any of you are wondering why I have nothing to say about Newham it's because the count isn't taking place until the morning. And Epsom & Ewell elects all its councillors at once and the elections there aren't until next year.)
01:10 - Nick Brown, a key ally of Gordon Brown, has just declined on air to say that he thinks Tony Blair an rebuild the damaged Labour Party. There are rumours that a groups of Labour MPs are writing a joint letter calling for Tony Blair to stand down.
01:11 - Conservatives hold Reigate & Banstead and Tandridge, the two Surrey councils to the east of Epsom & Ewell.
01:12 - I've just noticed that Kingston-Upon-Hull has stayed No Overall Control with the Lib Dems gaining four seats from other parties. Labour have lost only two seats in John Prescott's territory - but I'm not sure how many of the third of seats up for election they were defending.
01:16 - The London results aren't coming in just yet but there are reports the Lib Dems have lost control of Islington. They are defending thirty-six of the forty-eight seats there. Sarah Teather, a former Islington councillor, has let slip on air that there may be problems in the local party there but doesn't really know, despite this being repeatedly trumpeted as a Lib Dem flagship council. Are the Lib Dems more The Muppets Show or Clueless?
01:23 - Jeremy Vine is talking us through polls about the party standings and how David Cameron is perceived. 39% of voters think he is "tough" but Michael Howard at the equivalent stage had a 49% rating and apparently this is something Cameron has to make up. How can anyone compete here with the toughest Home Secretary since Jix?
01:29 - I've just been asked who was "Jix". The answer is Sir William Joynson-Hicks, Home Secretary in Stanley Baldwin's second government (1924-1929). "Jix", as he was popularly known, was a Home Secretary who could make Michael Howard's record look soft. He was a scourge of the roaring twenties, a fierce opponent of attempts to change the Prayer Book and also the man responsible for giving universal suffrage to women in the UK when he made a pledge that the government would do so without internal discussions and bound Baldwin into upholding the pledge. For more information, please see the Wikipedia article on him.
01:34 - Reports from Camden suggest Labour is facing loss for the first time in thirty-eight years. The Gospel Oak ward, where the Labour leader has his seat, may fall to the Conservatives despite being two-thirds council housing.
01:36 - Croydon looks uncertain. This borough is the strongest Conservative case for proportional representation - since 1994 Labour has won the council despite the Conservatives winning the popular vote (but as a supporter of first past the post I can't really complain). It's possible Labour have clung on in the north of the borough with a ferocious campaign.
01:37 - The current prediction for the BNP in Barking & Dagenham is eight to ten seats. And the latest reports suggest a lot of would-be BNP voters ripping up their papers in anger at not finding a candidate on the ballot paper and people ringing up the council to ask if they can vote BNP without a candidate (suggesting that the BNP is reaching out to people who don't normally vote in local elections).
01:56 - It got blocked out a bit by discussions but Crawley has just gone from Labour to Conservative control after over thirty years. A one seat Labour majority was converted into a one seat Conservative majority after a dead heat in the polls and drawing lots. People are asking if this is the fairest way to settle a tie but would it really be practical to rerun the entire election in that ward?
02:04 - The first London result is in. And it's...
Westminster. Conservatives hold. Let's hope the next borough to declare is an exciting one.
02:05 - The Greens have managed to get someone on the BBC for the first time tonight. Caroline Lucas is trying to talk up the results but so far they've only made a net gain of one councillor. She's also turning into a Lib Dem by falling back on blaming the electoral system for everything.
02:06 - Labour are currently riding a net loss of 115 seats with many to come.
02:08 - Another London result and this one is just as exciting. Wandsworth - Conservative hold.
02:18 - Labour lose Oldham. There are no BNP councillors. But will a No Overall Control council be able to deliver what the people need or will the BNP have more local issues to exploit next time?
02:19 - Another Surrey result - Conservatives gain Mole Valley, where I went to school for six years.
02:29 - A couple of small London results - the Labour leader on Havering council has lost his seat. In Hammersmith & Fulham the Conservatives have gained three seats in the first declared result, ousting former Labour MP, Ian Coleman from the council.
02:32 - Another London result that just oodles with excitement. Kensington & Chelsea - Conservatives hold.
02:39 - Declarations from Barking & Dagenham so far give the BNP eight seats. Margaret Hodge's comments last month have been attacked by many Labour activists and campaigners. Hodge is being interviewed on BBC1 now and trying to justify her comments, but I'm not tipping her to enter the Cabinet in the reshuffle.
02:52 - Stephen Twigg and Oona King have popped up on BBC1 - it's like old MPs reunited! The BBC are reporting rumours that Labour has gained Enfield but Twigg (famously once and equally famously no longer MP for Enfield Southgate) is sceptical.
02:56 - The Greens are now up seven, whilst the BNP are up twelve. UKIP have held one seat so far.
02:58 - BBC1 has a technical fault and goes off air midway through Tony King explaining that the two party system is breaking down. I'm not sure if the two are connected...
03:12 - Flicking over to Sky it seems the BNP in Barking & Dagenham are up to 11. There are also reports of Harrow going to "Other" but everyone's treating this as an error and it's being treated as a Conserative gain.
03:18 - Conservatives gain Bexley, smashing Labour to just nine seats.
03:19 - BBC1 is back on air with the election programme, albeit being fed from the London focused branch in the City.
03:20 - Is it me or is that Michael Portillo on BBC1 saying encouraging things about the current Conservative position for the first time in years?
03:22 - The London Borough of Sutton has stayed Liberal Democrat but their majority is heavily slashed ten, whilst the Labour group is wiped out.
03:29 - The Labour leader of Croydon, Tony Newman, has conceded defeat and is blaming "ten days of negative headlines" for the defeat. However there was also the local issue of massive increases in council tax. Oh and the Lib Dem group on the council has been wiped out.
03:31 - A spellcheck on this blog has a problem with "Dimbleby" and nominates "thimbleful" instead!
03:32 - It's reported that Labour has lost Lewisham to No Overall Control. However this is a borough with an elected Mayor so the party balance on the council is not the only key factor here.
03:38 - Camden is looking like another Labour loss, with the Lib Dems and Greens gaining seats. Frank Dobson (whose seat is here) is again blaming national headlines, along with the impact of the NHS deficits on the local hospitals and other national government policies coming out badly locally. A reshuffle - "changing the ship's officers on The Titanic" and he's calling for Blair to go.
03:40 - Another London result - a Breaking News flash says Labour have lost Merton.
03:44 - More London results. Merton has gone No Overall Control. Hillingdon has been gained by the Conservatives. There are no further rumours on Enfield going Labour. Hammersmith & Fulham looks likely to go Conservative, with the Labour leader conceding defeat.
03:49 - Labour are currently 189 councillors down. So just how bad will they concede tonight has been?
03:53 - I've just been informed that the Conservatives have gained Winchester from the Lib Dems. Perhaps Mark Oaten should not have reminded everyone of the scandal.03:55 - The Conservatives have gained Ealing. Many say "As goes Ealing, so goes the country" - it nearly always elects whoever wins the next election. Personally I think the next election will only be in the bag when the voters put it there.
03:58 - Power has been restored in Westminster and so David Dimbleby is back.
04:05 - The gaphics are starting to appear in the studio. The Conservatives are currently up 204, Labour down 205. So how much more bad news is piling up for Labour?
04:07 - The projected national share of the vote is Conservative 40%, Lib Dem 27%, Labour 26%, Others 7%.
04:19 - Conservatives hold Redbridge. Apart from in the south west it's looking like London will have a nice blue rim at the end of these results.
04:25 - Nick Griffin is being interviewed on BBC1 right now. He's denying BNP voters care about mixed marriages or mixed sexual partners and that it isn't a matter for legislation, despite what is on the BNP website. Amongst other policies he's explaining to David Dimbleby he's trying to justify a one menu fits all policy for school dinners as being for the sake of anoxeric young girls! Does anyone even in the BNP think such rubbish sound convincing, let along actually believe it?
04:33 - Just spotted another London result - Conservatives hold Bromley. The rim grows. And the Croydon gain is now confirmed.
04:34 - The first result from Tower Hamlets is in - the Lib Dems have lost three seats to Labour! This is one of the few shifts none of the commentators expected. My immediate reaction is that Labour are gaining votes amongst certain communities in Tower Hamlets as a reaction against RESPECT and as an attempt to shore them up. A similar effect was visible in the General Election.
04:38 - Looking at the map of London on the BBC's website the current state of play is:
Conservative councils - 11 (Hillingdon, Harrow, Ealing, Hammersmith & Fulham, Kensington & Chelsea, Westminster, Redbridge, Wandsworth, Croydon, Bromley, Bexley)
Labour - 1 (Haringey)
Lib Dems - 1 (Sutton)
No Overall Control - 3 (Islington, Merton, Lewisham)
Still to declare: 16 (Brent, Barnet, Camden, Enfield, Hackney, Waltham Forest, Tower Hamlets, Newham, Barking & Dagenham, Havering, Hounslow, Richmond upon Thames, Kingston upon Thames, Lambeth, Southwark, Greenwich)
No elections - City of London
04:49 - One of the points being picked up on now on BBC1 is that Labour is doing especially badly amongst the affluent middle classes (look in particular at the London map). Another point is that, as several emailers have pointed out, a lot of Labour politicians are talking about "listening to the people" but never seem to pick up the message of "go away".
04:53 - There's clearly an appetite for change in the government. Is simply dumping a few ministers, moving John Reid to yet another new job and promoting a few Ministers of State to the Cabinet (if that's possible) the kind of change both the people and the Labour Party want?
04:56 - Kingston upon Thames is held by the Lib Dems, losing five seats, whilst Labour lose one seat and the Conservatives gain six seats. The Lib Dem majority is now just two.
05:00 - David Dimbleby notes the Press Association reports that East London Labour chiefs are considering discipling Margaret Hodge for her comments publicising the BNP.
05:01 - The Lib Dems have gained Richmond upon Thames.
05:05 - Nick Robinson is predicting that although John Prescott will retain the title "Deputy Prime Minister", he will lose the department currently known as the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister.
05:07 - I've just noted on www.vote-2006.co.uk that the Conservatives now have a majority of councillors in the half of the London Borough of Sutton that makes up the Sutton & Cheam parliamentary seat. Meanwhile in the other half, the Carshalton & Wallington seat, a poster wrote:
As outgoing Labour Group Leader, Andrew Theobald said tonight - congratulations to Conservative Ken Andrew for becoming Carshalton & Wallington MP-electSo could the next general election see south west London ending the yellow days?
05:11 - It's now confirmed that Camden has gone from Labour to No Overall Control. However it seems Lambeth has gone the other way.
05:13 - David Campbell Bannerman, great nephew of the former Liberal Prime Minister and current chair of UKIP, has become the first UKIPer I've seen in the media all night. UKIP have been invisible in these elections and a single issue party offers nothing in terms of how to run town halls.
05:20 - More from Tower Hamlets. The Conservatives have gained six seats from Labour. None of the declared results so far have seen anyone hold their seats. The count is taking a long time because of all the accusations of electoral fraud have led to election officials proceeding very slowly.
05:23 - Enfield stays Conservative, Waltham Forest stays No Overall Control (and because a rim stain).
05:31 - BBC1's results have come to a close so I'm going to get some kip. Later we'll find out about the rest of the results, especially Newham and Tower Hamlets.
Thursday, May 04, 2006
77% of students oppose the marking boycott
What's interesting has been the reaction of the National Union of Students' leadership:
NUS president Kat Fletcher said: "Clearly there are strong opinions circulating on both sides of the debate across the two million members that we have in higher education.Those who have seen Yes Prime Minister will recall the classic scene when Humphrey explains to Bernard just how to rig a survey. Presumably Kat Fletcher would have liked such a survey to be conducted instead of an opinion poll.
"We know that some students are unhappy with the lecturers' decision to boycott assessment and we also have clear evidence of support for the teaching unions and the actions they have been forced to take."
Ms Fletcher said the survey might have elicited a different response if it had set out all the facts.
(Some may wish to claim the poll was rigged. However it was commissioned by London Student whose editorial line has been one of support for the boycott. The actual questions asked were "Do you support the lecturers' demands for higher pay disregarding their industrial action?" and "Do you support the lecturers boycotting the setting and marking of exams and coursework as part of their campaign for higher pay?" Furthermore the polling organisation has been identified and is one with a reputation, not a dodgey "private poll" of the kind in the Yes Prime Minister example.)
I should also note the rest of Kat's comments:
However, like all students I am concerned about the impact of the industrial action especially with the exam season under way.But from her comments overall it seems doubtful that the NUS leadership will respond to this clear expression of student opinion. One must seriously question whether the NUS mission values statement is being adhered to when it states:
I am particularly concerned that some students aren't even able to take their exams, because of the AUT policy not to set them," she said.
"We are really pleased that both sides will be getting back round the table, something which should have happened much earlier than this."
NUS will constantly improve the lives and experiences of students in the UK: by ensuring their voice is heard and effectively represented; by developing democratic and strong students’ unions; and by providing collective benefits and access to information for all students.Now the NUS leadership may want to argue for the trustee model of representation rather than the delegate model of representation. But traditionally NUS has gone with the delegate model of representation and it's rather suspicious to change stance just when the existing model happens to deliver a different result from the one wanted.
As well as my earlier post about Adam Sloan's experience of the boycott, here are two more individual accounts. Firstly The Independent Online Edition has Portia Hart: Why I would fight the AUT to get my degree whilst BBC News has Jacqueline Berry's account of her waiting game. Here at Queen Mary we've been lucky that the deadline for submitting exam papers fell before the boycott started, but many students are still concerned that they will not be able to graduate and take up graduate jobs and postgraduate places. At other universities students don't even know if they'll be able to sit their exams.
Let's hope this poll helps bring the action to a conclusion very soon.
Bizarre search terms
* labour party condom jokes on Google - there's not another round of stories about private lives coming is there?
* why aren't one-day travelcards on oyster - indeed why not?
Wednesday, May 03, 2006
Quietness
When the exams are over I'll post my thoughts on these - all I'll say now is that it's the first time I've been inside an exam room in five years!
Monday, May 01, 2006
On "love"
The term "love" is frankly overused in society. Sometimes it gets used in ways that seem excessive such as "I love Cadbury's Cream Eggs", perhaps reflecting the language's lack of a single word verb that means "really really like/enjoy". It also gets used a lot to describe states of affairs such as friendships and familial ties where another word would suffice. Again, the English language lets us down. (Translations of the Bible have often been plagued by some words in the original text sharing an English word or the opposite.) There is also the use of the term by some branches of science to refer to what is more accurately lust.
But to use love in its strictest sense, a synergistic connection, on examination it looks like a complete illusion. The idea that two souls can be bound together is fundamentally against the basic concept of the soul's freedom. Moreover, the evidence that people who say they are "in love" actually are, as opposed to thinking that they are, is very absent.
Over the years, many have tried to "prove" that love exists to me. But their arguments have usually fallen into the same areas:
*"I love [some random name, whom I might add they are almost always no longer "loving"] and they love me" - which is just an expression of something they think. I have known many people swear blind that what they are thinking and feeling is fact (I remember one time when a person swore blind they were a famous author!), yet to detached eyes it is clear that they are not.
*"What you feel for your family" - which is basically mutual support and duty.
*"It happens to us all, one day you're going to feel it" - some meaningless jargon which is easy to disprove (one need only look at the large number of relatives of mine who lived long lives completely and fortunately devoid of relationships).
*"The Bible says it" - but this comes down to translation and the words available.
I am also not sold that relationships are A Good Thing either - almost every single relationship I have seen up close has been a very strong argument for wanting to avoid them completely. When I think of the pain, misery, despair, violence and attempted suicides I cannot but feel that I never want to be in such a state of affairs. Quite a few have promised that they can show "good" relationships but with one exception (who I do not think are even aware of my views, at least until they have read this) I have yet to see one. One solitary exception is insufficient to convince me.
A few others have sent me their thoughts on what they think "love" is. One wrote "love for anything is being excited when you wake up in the morning and being able to laugh or cry about it" which seems to be stretching the concept so broadly that it does not really mean anything. Another offered a poem:
Love is lightIt again seems to be referring to the "force of love" but does not in anyway prove anything beyond that people think it is there.
Love is bright
Love is like a candle with an infinite life
Love is hurtful
Love brings delight
Love is mutual
Love is strong
Love is an invisible connection between two human beings
Love lasts forever even when our time has come.
Maybe I am wrong - those who have known me for some time know that I have changed my mind on some pretty major stuff in the past when presented with new evidence and circumstances. However, on this to date no one has really offered anything substantial.
Another Charles in the last chance saloon?
Bungling Home Secretary Charles Clarke did NOT offer to quit last week over the freed foreign convicts scandal.Also Clarke apparently kept the news about the lack of deportations from the Prime Minister for three weeks.
He told the BBC he had offered to go — which infuriated Prime Minister Tony Blair.
The PM stormed out of the Commons on Wednesday after being humiliated about his refusal to accept the "phantom" resignation.
Clarke has given an interview to the EPD24 website stating:
At the end of the day, my own political future depends on my own strength of character dealing with the points that are raised, first, secondly on the support of my own political colleagues, and thirdly and most importantly on the decisions of the prime minister.So does he still have that support? I doubt it. A letter accepting Clarke's resignation is bound to be sitting on Blair's desk. When will the letter offering it arrive?
If I lost that support, that would be different. I hope I will continue as home secretary.
April on this blog
First off the sites most people come from:
- Blogger.com (+1)
- Google (-1)
- Conservative Mind (+3)
- Take back the voice (NEW)
- Jo Salmon (-)
- Antonia Bance (-3)
- Contemplative Activist (-)
- Vote 2006 Discussion Forum (NEW)
- A Tangled Web (NEW)
- Adloyada (NEW)
Dropping out of the top ten altogether are Educationet (at 12, down 9), Wikipedia (at 23, down 13), Dan Quixote - Tilting At Political Windmills Blog (at 28, down 20) and Liberal England (which has disappeared from the listings altogether).
Jo and her partner Antonia have swapped order once again - I'm still waiting to find out if this causes rows in the Salmon-Bance home!
Then we have the top ten search engine requests that brought people here:
- laura blomeley (-)
- what does your birthday say about you (+1)
- sutton labour manifesto (NEW)
- tim roll-pickering (-2)
- Kat Stark letter (NEW)
- edmonton bars without grumpy old men (NEW)
- arnold schwarzenegger in forest gate (NEW)
- stratford station protection from falling collision impact (NEW)
- labour in sutton (NEW)
- james juggapah (NEW)
Otherwise again nearly all the terms have changed, with few if any people looking for information about 'shabina begun jilbab', 'sexism nowadays', 'abortions in oxted', 'qmsu referendum success', 'female conservatives stupid', 'my cat loves custard' and 'council tax students exemption opsi'.
Quite a few searches relating to politics in Sutton have been from the domain sutton.gov.uk - i.e. The London Borough of Sutton. With the recent exchange between Daniel Snowdon and myself about where Sutton is, I wonder if the popularity of Sutton in searches coming here will increase.
Finally we have a list of all the cities detected that people are in (although many are listed as "other"):
LONDON, NEWPORT, COVENTRY, BROOKLYN, WASHINGTON, LEUVEN, MANCHESTER, OXFORD, TORONTO, CAMBRIDGE, NORTHAMPTON, DUNDEE, ATLANTA, SWANSEA, FLORENCE, NOTTINGHAM, DULLES, SHEFFIELD, BELFAST, CARDIFF, ABERDEEN, NEW YORK, SOUTHAMPTON, BRADFORD, MANASSAS, SHADY SIDE, MOUNTAIN VIEW, BANGKOK, EDINBURGH, READING, BIRMINGHAM, WARRINGTON, CEDAR PARK, SANTA CRUZ DE TENERIFE, SINGAPORE, BRISTOL, THE HAGUE, MELBOURNE, MINNEAPOLIS, LUTON, LOS ANGELES, LIVERPOOL, CROYDON, WOODBRIDGE, MIDDLETOWN, LEICESTER, BERGEN, BATAVIA
(As ever this is not always perfect - for some reason readers at both the University of Kent and Canterbury Christ Church University are listed as being in London. Canterbury is not exactly next to London!)
Once more, thanks to everyone who's been reading and contributing to this blog!
Since when was a free choice compelled?
In a free democracy people have the moral right to not participate in voting. And the level of voter turnout is often a reflection of engagement. There is no point just making voting compulsory and pretend that it will solve the problems of political engagement in this country. That would be like using a sticking plaster on a broken limb.
One country that does have compulsory voting is Australia. Now whilst that country has some good features (at the last election they elected Mr. Howard as Prime Minister!) compulsory voting may not be the best thing for the country's politics. Here are a few comments from a mixture of blogs:
Dispatches From the Moderate Left says:
The other major practical argument for a compulsory franchise is that when voting is voluntary the people who are least likely to vote are poor and marginal social groups and that it's important that these people's opinions have an effect on political decisions. This seems persuasive, but I'd question whether it has any real effect. There are countries with voluntary voting which do much better for their poor than we do (see my upcoming picture of the week). I don't think there's persuasive evidence that forcing marginalised groups to vote leads to better outcomes for them.The Thin Man Returns' take on this is:
A final argument put forward for compulsory voting is that there's nothing wrong with forcing citizens to take half an hour every three years to participate in the voting process. Voting, like taxation, is a social duty which is rightly enforced by the government. This argument looks circular to me. Sure, the state can make people do a whole lot of things if it wants to and call them civil duties, but unless there's some practical benefit then it's kind of pointless. Taxes get government money. Forcing people to vote does what? Educates them about the voting system? Makes people less apathetic? Improves voting outcomes? I don't think it does any of these things.
There's still enormous amounts of apathy among the general public about politics most of the time and the extra attention that compulsory voting creates around election time just encourages the sort of middle class spending bonanza which burdens us with the private health care rebate, the baby bonus, rural spending rorts and 3 yearly bribes for old people. Coverage an attention focuses on whether or not such and such a demographic will be financially better off under which party and there's no constituency for spending restraint and reform (did anyone complain about the baby bonus except to say that it wasn't enough money?). The race for the vital center, from what I've seen in Australian elections, is just a race to spend the most money on middle class groups who may be able to swing marginal seats. It's not political moderation and it's certainly not appeals to poor/marginalised groups who might not vote if voting was voluntary.
What's more, making a lot of a-political people vote means that the chance of irrational voting patterns is even higher than in other countries. By irrational voting I'm talking donkey voting or voting for the guy who has the best campaign image/five second sound bite. Literally half of the people I spoke to after the last Australian election voted for Howard because Latham was ugly and/or did that really weird handshake thing. Sure these people have a right to vote because of these things if they want, but I don't think that increasing the number of these sorts of votes is a good policy outcome.
I believe the stunningly low standard of political candidates in Australia is due almost entirely to compulsory voting. If the parties really had to fight to get voters out, they would be more interested in being truly responsive to the electorate and fielding quality candidates.And a British take from The Right Way:
As it stands, with many voters leaning left or right 'because me dad did' (or 'because me dad voted for the others') or simply because they like or don't like the look of a candidate, the advantage of non-compulsory voting is, quite frankly, that it allows morons who'd vote according to the above or any other daft reason to voluntarily disengage from the process and leaves the selection of government to those who actually care and think criticially about how they cast their vote.
I suspect this would result, over a period of time, in higher standards of political discourse generally.
I might add the above concept isn't original - I saw it advanced many years ago with reference, I think, to voting in the Netherlands. The comment was to the effect that one could trace the level to which government was engaging effectively with the people by the level of voter turnout. Parties and governments used turnout as a kind of barometer which showed that if turnout was falling, they needed to lift their game.
Here in Australia, however, why try to lift your game? You can keep fielding the same old tired candidates and young cannon fodder with no worries because turnout is guaranteed to be high - on penalty of a fine.
We can see compulsory voting in operation in Australia. The result has been that the parties don't have to worry about turnout. The reason why Lynton Crosby's antics were so successful in Australia is that if Party A destroys the credibility of Party B, the public still has to vote for someone - apathy or abstention is not an option. So how better to vote for than the only party left with any credibility. It creates a vicious circle leading to more and more negative campaigning.For those not familiar with the Australian election system, they use the Alternative Vote for the House of Representatives and the Single Transferable Vote for the Senate. Combined with compulsory voting this produces some of the worst cast votes of all.
Moreover as the parties know that the 30-40% of the electorate who are forced out to vote, have no real interest in the body politic, and therefore no party allegiances, they adopt populist "dog whistle" issues to grab that floating vote. The result is that issues like immigration become the key swing issue in an election campaign, and are always played in a mean spirited way.
In what way is this form of politics something for us to aspire to?
Informal voting is when a voter does not number every box on the ballot paper with their order of preferences. If a voter does not use all their preferences their vote becomes invalid. Donkey voting is when a voter simply numbers the ballot in the order in which the candidates are listed - is this really a voter participating wisely in the democratic process?
Because of this many parties will print "How to Vote" cards indicating how they want their supporters to use their transfers. That works for the House of Representatives where the voter can be faced with up to a dozen candidates (who are now listed in random order following a plethora of candidates with surnames beginning with "A" getting elected). But for the Senate a voter may have to decide between getting close to a hundred candidates. The solution is to allow a voter to either cast a full set of transfers (voting "below the line") or to case an "above the line" vote by choosing a political party and casting a single vote for them. The vote is then redistributed according to the list already nominated by the party. This can lead to horse-trading between parties - again is this really such a good thing?
A lot of people argue that the recent electoral successes by the BNP are because of low turnout and that getting more people to the polls will negate their chances. Now whilst an increased turnout amongst the middle classes may boost the anti-BNP vote (although anyone who thinks the BNP's appeal is exclusively working class need only to look at a map of all their victories to see how this is an illusion) but dragging people to the polling booths who are anti-politics can only boost the vote for a party that is "anti-politics". Extreme parties thrive on despair and disillusionment amongst voters. Forcing them to the polls would only be doing part of the BNP's work for them.
Let's not make hasty changes to the voting system to provide a quick fix to problems of political engagement. It will do nothing to enhance voter engagement and the quality of political discourse, nor will it marginalise extremes. These are problems that need to be cured, not shored up.